Showing posts with label legal intimidation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label legal intimidation. Show all posts

Monday, January 07, 2013

Book Review: "CULT" by William Howell

One of the things the TM movement promises is that the practice of TM leads to "enlightenment."  During his lifetime, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi confirmed that a very few people had reached enlightenment through his technique.

One of those people was Robin Carlsen, a TM teacher who, on a TM course in Switzerland in the 1970s, had an overwhelming experience of the divinity, beauty and unity of the creation.  At a subsequent course meeting, he described his experience to Mahesh (MMY).  Mahesh pronounced that Carlsen was "somewhere in the layers of wholeness."  Most course participants attending interpreted Mahesh's words to mean that that Carlsen had reached enlightenment.  (Mahesh never contradicted their belief.)

About a decade later, Carlsen, in the midst of lawsuits and countersuits against the TM organization, agreed to put the lawsuits to rest if Mahesh would unequivocally answer four questions.  The first question was, "Is Robin Carlsen enlightened?"  Mahesh answered "No."

We'll never know what Mahesh meant the first time.  However, after Mahesh's first comment, in Switzerland, Carlsen was generally believed by TMers to be "enlightened."  Carlsen then went on to slowly establish his own courses, techniques, ashram.  Over time, as he became more self-centered, manipulative and sadistic, his organization became spiritually and emotionally destructive and ground down the self-confidence and mental health of his followers.

William Howell, the author of "CULT," has changed most names in this memoir, but not the facts.  The name "Robin Carlsen" is never mentioned.  Instead, the former TM teacher at the center of this story is called "Justin Snow."  But this reviewer (that's me, Laurie) and  others believe that the book is about Robin Carlson.

The book "CULT" by William Howell tells the true story of how Howell, (then a TM teacher) had accompanied "Justin Snow" on his stroll in the Swiss Alps on the day that "Snow" had his divine experience.  Howell goes on to tell of how he followed Snow, lived at his community, followed his teachings, attended his courses, and suffered through years of increasing degradation and emotional stress until he left.  His other friends gradually left too.  They then helped each other, through mutual support, to exit, deprogram and rebuild their lives.  This book is that story of Howell's closing days with TM, his entry into Carlson's destructive cult, and his leaving and healing afterwards.  

I found this book fascinating because I have always wondered what a person would be like when they had reached the goal of "enlightenment" that we TMers were all ardently devoting ourselves to under Maharishi's guidance.  I also found this book helpful in that it detailed the exit and recovery of Howell and his friends.

You can read the book for free online here:


http://www.free-ebooks.net/ebook/CULT-A-Memoir/pdf/view

In the copyright section of the book, William Howell writes:  "This book is copyrighted solely to prevent its being misused.  People sincere about spiritual development, peace and growth of human awareness throughout the world have the author's permission to reproduce material from this book - with citing."

You can also read more about Robin Carlsen on TM-Free blog.  (Note tags/labels related to this post.)

Friday, July 03, 2009

Legal Intimidation Transcendental Meditation's New Spiritual Technique?

In the last few months, there have been a number of reports of various arms of the TM Org threatening legal action against critics, usually for copyright or trademark infringement.

My webinar protesting teaching TM in public schools was threatened by Bill Goldstein, who claimed to represent MVED. This resulted in me canceling the webinar.

Natural Stress Relief USA reports being pursued by TM Org lawyers claiming trademark infringement.

Jim Nemmers, claiming to represent Maharishi Foundation, Ltd. demanded we delete TMFB posts that he felt infringed copyright.

Steve Sashen gives a report of how his Web site was threatened:

I received a cease-and-desist letter from the same organization about my post at http://www.meditationtruth.com/l...ee- instructions

Their original argument had some merit, so I made changes to the post to make it clear that:

a) That you can find the TM instructions in books and online at no cost
b) I wasn't teaching TM
c) The technique on the post isn't TM

They also took issue with my opinions (shared by a number of well-respected publications) that the TM "studies" were not as rigorous as they are presented and, more likely, don't prove what the TM people want them to prove.

And, similarly, they didn't like that I compared the simple mantra meditation on that post to TM (another mantra meditation) saying that I couldn't PROVE that it could be as effective.

I wasn't aware that I had to PROVE an opinion (I don't).

Their last contact insisted that I put a "disclaimer" on my site which looked a lot more like an AD for TM than a disclaimer.
Steven Sashen

We are going to track these threats and publicize them as one means to fight the TM Org's attempts at what look like intimidation.

If you know of any individuals or groups that have recently received threatening communications from TM Org representatives, please post them in the comments below or email me directly at jmknapp53@gmail.com .

I am organizing a Twitter campaign to publicize TM's legal shenanigans. Search for #TM_Critics.

I see strong parallels between TM's apparent attempts to silence critics with similar efforts of Scientology.

Is that really the model that TM leaders wish to emulate?


Please Help Us Defend Ourselves against Transcendental Meditation Bullying

You may know the "Maharishi Foundation, Ltd." legally threatened us for alleged copyright violations because I publicly posted Transcendental Meditation Movement insider emails. Emails that they had requested be forwarded to all interested parties! (You can read the redacted versions below. Just look for recent posts with FBI-style blackened text.)

How do you spell Transcendental Meditation? S-c-i-e-n-t-o-l-o-g-y!

But we are not without defenses! You, our readers, are our secret weapon.

Please consider posting about this attack on your Facebook, MySpace, or Twitter streams. Or emailing to any friend that may have a sincere interest.

Together we can stop their outrageous attempts to silence critics by shedding light on TM's dark secrets through public knowledge.

Here's the tweet I'm hoping will be retweeted to make their outrageous attack on free speech viral.

Transcendental Meditation trying to silence critics. Pls help! RT to make outrageous legal threats viral. http://bit.ly/FEfN2

Would you consider posting such a message to your social networking accounts or email?

If you do post a message, please let us know in the comments to this post. Just click on "Comments" below and share your feelings and actions around this issue.

Thanks for all your support!


Transcendental Meditation Spa More Costly than Carribbean Cruise!



UPDATE: Bumped from June 20, 2009. I redacted the post below to attempt to meet the demands of Jim Nemmers, Esq., of Shuttleworth & Ingersoll, P.L.C., who claims to represent the Maharishi Foundation Ltd., England. He states that MFL owns the copyright to the email and the service marks and trademarks in the email below.


(Interestingly, a little sweat applied to a Google search box reveals that MFL appears to be a nonprofit corporation dormant for 10 years — without assets, without any mention of intellectual property assets.)


I believe my original post met the requirements for a Fair Use exception to copyright laws, being news, information, criticism, educational, and parodic, as well as being for a non-commercial purpose. In fact, I thought the full post served the TM Org well by providing the entire context of their email so readers could make their own informed opinions about the material presented.


I've got to wonder why Jim and his client MFL are scared of us publishing their own, exact words in full context. Especially when these emails are typically accompanied by requests to share them with any interested parties.


This is a temporary response to Jim's demands, as I research with our advisers how copyright and intellectual property rights apply to this situation.



Of course, you can't get enlightened on a Carribbean cruise.


Oh, wait. You can't get enlightened on any TM Org course either.


My bad.


Thanks to our anonymous TMFB reader who shares so much about current TM Org programs.


Provided for discussion purposes only. We urge all readers to exercise caution before engaging in any TM Org&endash;sponsored activity!



Dear John,


10 days of treatment regularly cost $7324! Both my husband and I have gone on holidays together in the Carribbean during our winter that cost us less for the
both of us!




















From: National Office of Communication Date: June 19, 2009 11:28:27 AM MDT
To: <Xxxxx>

Subject: Discover the new Lancaster Ayurveda Health Center Reply-To: info@lancasterhealth.com





  • Discover the new Lancaster Ayurveda Health Center




  • xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxx




  • xxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx



  • xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx




  • xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx



  • xxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx




  • xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx/span>


xxx, xxx xxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx (xxxx) xx xxxxxxxxx! xx xxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxxx, xxx xxxx xxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xx xxx xxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx. xx xxxx, xxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxx, x.x., xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xx xxx xxx, xxxxxxx. xxxxx, xxx xxx xx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xx xxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xx,xxx xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxx x xxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxx.




xxxxx xxxxxxxx xx x xxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx. xxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxx xx x xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx.


For more information xxxxxx xxxx xx xxxx xxxx xx xxx-xxx-xxxx, xx xxxxx xxxx xx x-xxxx xx.


xxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx



A Special Welcome for our July* Guests: With our compliments, enjoy a healthful gift basket, sent directly to your home. *(for guests enjoying treatment packages of 5 or more days)



Lancaster Summer Specials



xxxx xxxxxx, xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xx xxxx xxxx—x xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxxx, xxxx xxx xxxxxx. xxxxx xx xx xxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx. xxxx xxx xxx xxxx xxxxxxxxx xx xxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxxxx. xxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxx xxxx x xx xxxxxx xx.



xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx, xxx xxx xxxxx. xx xxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxx, xxxx xxxxxxx, xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx.


Two Day Rejuvenation Weekend xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx



  • 1 night/2 days xxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx
    Regular Price: $1,119.00 Now: $975.00 save $144.00


  • Five Day Revitalizing Package xxxx xxxxxx xxx xxxx, xxxx, xxx xxxx

    6 nights/5 days xxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx.
    xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx


    Regular Price: $3,829.00 Now: $3,330.00 save $499.00

  • Seven Day Renew and Cleanse Program xxxxxx, xxxxxx, xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx

    8 nights/7 days xxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx
    xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx
    xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx


    Regular Price: $5,227.00 Now: $4,547.00 save $680.00


  • Ten Day Royal Rejuvenation Package xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxxxxxxx, xxx xxxxxx.
    xx xxxxxx/xx xxxx xxxx xxxxx, xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx
    xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx.
    xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxx xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxx


    Price: $7,324.00 Now: $6,372.00 save $952.00



xxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxx. • xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx: xxxxxx xxxxx, x.x., xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxx xxxxxx




  • xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx: xxxxxxx xxxxxx, x.x., xxxxxxxx, xxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxx




  • xxxxxxx xxxxxxx: xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxx xx xxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx xx xxxx xx xxx xxxxx'x xxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xxx xxxx.

With warm regards from Lancaster,


Your Maharishi Ayurveda Team



xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxxxxx | xxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxx | xxxxxxxxx, xx xxxxx


xxxxxxxxxxx xxx xxxxxxxxxxxx. xxx-xxx-xxxx (xxxx-xxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxxx xxxx), xxx-xxx-xxxx. xxx: xxx-xxx-xxxx x-xxxx:xxxx@xxxxxxxx-xxxxxxxxx.xxx | xxx.xxxxxxxx-xxxxxxxxx.xxx




Please feel free to forward this e-mail to your friends and family.






Thursday, July 02, 2009

Transcendental Meditation Rattles Our Chains -- Yet Again

Another day. Another adversarial letter from a lawyer representing a TM organization asking us to shut something down.

Ho-hum.

I redacted two posts, here and here, to attempt to meet the demands of Jim Nemmers, Esq., of Shuttleworth & Ingersoll, P.L.C., who claims to represent the Maharishi Foundation Ltd., England. He states that MFL owns the copyright to the email and the service marks and trademarks in two emails I posted.

(Interestingly, a little sweat applied to a Google search box reveals that MFL appears to be a nonprofit corporation dormant for 10 years — without assets, without any mention of intellectual property assets.)

I believe my original posts met the requirements for a Fair Use exception to copyright laws, being news, information, criticism, educational, and parodic, as well as being for a non-commercial purpose. In fact, I thought the full posts served the TM Org well by providing the entire context of their email so readers could make their own informed opinions about the material presented.

I've got to wonder why Jim and his client MFL are scared of us publishing their own, exact words in full context. Especially when these emails are typically accompanied by requests to share them with any interested parties.

This is a temporary response to Jim's demands, as I research with our advisers how copyright and intellectual property rights apply to this situation.